Loading NHL scores...

Connor McDavid vs. Auston Matthews: The Best in the World vs. One of the NHL’s Elite?

Share
FacebookXReddit

Two first-overall picks. Two franchise faces. Two very different paths to superstardom.

There are great players in the NHL, there are superstars, and then there is Connor McDavid.

The Edmonton Oilers captain has established himself as the best hockey player on the planet, combining breathtaking speed, unmatched offensive creativity and an ability to take over games that few players in NHL history have ever possessed. Whether he’s setting up Leon Draisaitl, slicing through an opposing defence or carrying his team on his shoulders in the playoffs, McDavid continues to set the standard for what an elite offensive player looks like.

But what about Auston Matthews?

The Toronto Maple Leafs captain entered the league with enormous expectations, quickly established himself as one of hockey’s most dangerous goal scorers and became the face of a franchise desperate to return to championship glory. At his peak, Matthews wasn’t simply a great goal scorer. He was one of the most feared offensive players in the entire NHL.

However, after two seasons that saw his production fall from the heights of his record-breaking 2023–24 campaign, the conversation has changed.

McDavid continues to operate at an extraordinary level, while Matthews has faced questions about his consistency, availability and ability to carry Toronto through the most important moments of the season.

So, let’s ask the question: We all know McDavid is the greatest hockey player on the planet right now, but does Auston Matthews still deserve to be considered among the elite of the elite?

Two Different Roads to the Top

Connor McDavid — Edmonton Oilers

Drafted first overall in 2015

McDavid arrived in Edmonton as a generational prospect and has exceeded even the enormous expectations placed on him. His game is built around speed, vision and playmaking, and he has led the league in scoring six times, most recently in 2025–26, when he put up 138 points in 82 games.

Auston Matthews — Toronto Maple Leafs

Drafted first overall in 2016

Matthews entered the league with a different calling card: an elite release, exceptional positioning and the ability to score goals in bunches. His 69-goal, 107-point season in 2023–24 was the peak of his regular-season production and reinforced his status as one of hockey’s premier goal scorers.

Both players became the faces of their respective franchises, but their styles tell different stories.

McDavid is the engine that drives an offence. He can create scoring chances seemingly out of nothing, turn a defensive-zone recovery into a breakaway and make the players around him more dangerous.

Matthews is a finisher. His ability to find open ice, release the puck quickly and score from difficult angles makes him one of the most naturally gifted goal scorers of his generation.

Comparing them strictly by goals misses McDavid’s playmaking advantage. Comparing them strictly by assists misses Matthews’ ability to change a game with a single shot.

They are both exceptional talents. The question is how far apart they have become.

The Numbers Tell an Interesting Story

Their regular-season production over the last three seasons tells the story.

In 2023–24, Matthews scored an extraordinary 69 goals, more than double McDavid’s 32. McDavid still finished with more points, 132 to 107, but that season demonstrated that Matthews could compete with the very best offensive players in the league.

But the following seasons told a different story.

McDavid remained a powerhouse in 2024–25, putting up 100 points in just 67 games, and then reached another level in 2025–26 with 138 points. Matthews, meanwhile, went from 107 points to 78 and then 53.

There is an important qualification: Matthews played just 60 games in 2025–26 before a knee injury ended his season, so his total doesn’t tell the whole story of his scoring ability. Injuries and missed games matter when evaluating a player’s season, and a reduced total doesn’t automatically mean a player has lost his talent.

Still, the decline across two seasons is significant enough to raise questions.

McDavid has continued to separate himself from the pack. Matthews needs to show that his peak wasn’t an isolated high point in an otherwise more inconsistent stretch.

McDavid’s Biggest Advantage: He Controls the Entire Game

What separates McDavid from almost everyone else isn’t simply his point total. It’s the number of ways he can affect a game.

He can score, set up teammates, draw defenders out of position and create advantages before the puck even reaches the scoring area. His speed forces opposing teams to adjust their defensive structure, and his vision allows him to exploit the smallest mistakes.

That versatility is why McDavid can have an enormous impact even when he isn’t scoring himself.

Matthews has plenty of dimensions to his game, including defensive awareness and a strong two-way centre’s skill set. But his reputation and greatest value remain closely connected to his goal scoring.

When Matthews is scoring at an elite rate, he can change the complexion of a game. When that production drops, the questions become louder because so much of his identity is tied to finding the back of the net.

McDavid doesn’t face the same scrutiny when his goal total dips because his playmaking can continue to drive the Oilers’ offence.

That’s the difference between being an elite goal scorer and being the league’s most complete offensive force.

The Team Factor: Edmonton vs. Toronto

Individual numbers only tell part of the story. A player’s supporting cast, coaching, roster construction and playoff opportunities all matter.

Edmonton has built its identity around McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, giving the Oilers two of the league’s most dangerous offensive weapons. That combination creates enormous pressure on opposing teams and gives Edmonton multiple ways to generate offence.

The Oilers also reached the Stanley Cup Final in consecutive seasons in 2024 and 2025. Although they fell short both times, those runs demonstrated that McDavid’s team could survive multiple rounds of playoff pressure and reach the sport’s biggest stage. Last spring was a step back, with Edmonton knocked out by Anaheim in the first round, but those two Final runs still set the Oilers apart.

Toronto’s story has been much more frustrating.

The Maple Leafs have assembled talented rosters around Matthews, including high-end offensive players, but their playoff runs have repeatedly ended before they could reach the conference final. Last season was even tougher, as Toronto missed the playoffs entirely for the first time since 2015–16. That lack of postseason progress has become part of the conversation surrounding Matthews’ legacy.

It would be unfair to put every Toronto playoff disappointment on its captain. Hockey is a team sport, and a centre cannot single-handedly fix defensive breakdowns, inconsistent goaltending or an offence that goes quiet at the wrong time.

But franchise players are judged by more than their regular-season statistics. Eventually, the expectation is that they will help lead their teams deeper into the playoffs.

McDavid has demonstrated that ability by reaching the Final twice. Matthews still has to get Toronto back into the playoffs and turn its talent into a longer postseason run.

Advantage: McDavid and Edmonton, based on playoff results and demonstrated success on the biggest stage.

Does Auston Matthews Still Belong Among the Elite of the Elite?

Here’s where the debate gets interesting.

If we’re discussing the best goal scorers in hockey, Matthews absolutely belongs in the conversation. His three Rocket Richard Trophies, his 69-goal season and his 2021–22 Hart Memorial Trophy as league MVP aren’t achievements that disappear because of two difficult seasons.

Those accomplishments prove that Matthews has already reached a level very few players ever achieve.

But being one of the league’s elite goal scorers and being one of the very best all-around players in the NHL are two different discussions.

The very top tier should be reserved for players who consistently influence games, produce at an extraordinary level and demonstrate that they can perform under the most demanding circumstances.

McDavid has continued to check those boxes. His production, playmaking and postseason accomplishments give him a strong argument as the NHL’s premier player.

Matthews has more to prove right now.

He needs to demonstrate that he can return to consistently elite offensive production, remain available for a full season and help Toronto make meaningful progress in the playoffs. If he does that, the debate about his standing among the NHL’s best will change quickly.

There is also a distinction between losing elite status and no longer being the best of the best. Matthews hasn’t erased his achievements, and one or two difficult seasons shouldn’t erase a career’s worth of excellence.

However, the standard for the very top tier is exceptionally high.

The 5 For Fighting Verdict

Connor McDavid is the best hockey player in the world right now. His production, creativity and ability to take over games make him the benchmark against which other NHL superstars are measured.

Auston Matthews is still an elite player, but his place in the elite of the elite is a fair question after his recent decline in production.

Matthews has already demonstrated that he can dominate the league as a goal scorer. His 69-goal season is proof of that. But the next stage of his career is about showing that he can consistently return to that level and turn individual success into meaningful team success.

We shouldn’t forget how good Matthews has been simply because his last two seasons haven’t matched his peak. At the same time, reputation alone shouldn’t guarantee a player a place among the league’s very best.

McDavid has kept raising the bar. Matthews needs to show he can rise back to meet it.

Our final take: McDavid is in a class of his own right now. Matthews remains one of the NHL’s most dangerous players when he’s at his best, but he needs a bounce-back season and a deeper playoff run to silence the doubters.

The talent is still there. Now it’s about consistency, health and results.

And if Matthews gets back to scoring at a 60-goal pace while helping Toronto finally break through in the playoffs, this conversation could look very different.

Who’s your pick? Is Connor McDavid in a league of his own, and does Auston Matthews still belong among the NHL’s elite of the elite?

Let us know in the comments.

Share this article

FacebookXReddit

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Partner With Us

Sponsor 5 For Fighting

Put your brand in front of hockey fans who check scores, standings, and stats every day.

  • Podcast sponsorships
  • Site banner ads
  • Custom partnerships
Scroll to Top