Every job site I’ve ever worked on has two kinds of people. There are the guys with the clipboards and clean boots, and there are the guys in the ditch at 6 a.m. with mud up to their knees. Both matter. But only one of them gets the building finished.
Hockey is no different. Right now the Maple Leafs bottom six is the crew in the ditch, and it’s the biggest reason this team looks nothing like the one that face-planted last spring.
Toronto went into Edmonton on Saturday and hammered the Oilers 7-2 for a fourth straight win, moving to 7-4-2. As a Leafs fan living in Edmonton, that one felt good. But look at who scored. Along with the usual suspects, Troy Stecher, Zack MacEwen and Vinni Lettieri all lit the lamp. That’s not an accident.

Officers and NCOs: The Military Math of a Hockey Team
The military figured this out a long time ago. Officers draw up the plan. Non-commissioned officers, the corporals and sergeants, make it happen. Ask anyone who’s served and they’ll tell you the army runs on its NCOs.
On the Leafs, Auston Matthews and William Nylander are the colonels. They get the power play, the offensive zone starts and the big contracts. Matthews carries a $13.25 million cap hit and Nylander $11.5 million. That’s officer pay, and they’ve earned it.
Then there are the corporals. Nick Paul, Teddy Blueger, Brandon Duhaime, Zack MacEwen. Guys who’ll score 10 to 20 in a good year, kill every penalty you send them out for, and block a slap shot with their ankle without thinking twice. Add up the cap hits for Paul, Blueger, Duhaime, MacEwen and Stecher and you get roughly $10.5 million. Five NCOs for less than one colonel. That’s a good deal in any army.
What Makes a Blue Collar Hockey Player
You won’t always find it on the scoresheet, but you know one when you see one.
They kill penalties. Shorthanded time is the hardest two minutes in hockey, and these guys volunteer for it every night.
They block shots. Not with the shin pad when it’s convenient. With whatever body part gets there first.
They win the walls. Cycling, grinding and digging pucks out of corners so the skill guys get them back clean.
They finish their checks. Every hit on a defenceman in the first period is a deposit that pays out in the third.
They protect their own. Touch the goalie and you’re going to hear about it.
They answer the bell. When somebody needs to drop the gloves, they don’t look around the room for a volunteer.
They don’t complain about ice time. Nine minutes or nineteen, they play it exactly the same.
The Shifts Nobody Wants
It’s also about the shifts you get handed. The defensive zone faceoff so the top line can start its next shift in the offensive end. The shift right after a goal against, when the building goes quiet and somebody has to reset the tone. The energy shift when the bench is flat. The last minute of a one-goal game with the other goalie pulled, when every puck goes off the glass and out. And the matchup shift, where you get thrown over the boards against the other team’s best line and told to survive.
None of those shifts make the sportscast. All of them decide hockey games.
Meet the Maple Leafs Bottom Six
New GM John Chayka didn’t go shopping for depth scoring this summer. He went after forwards who could handle defensive assignments, take draws and kill penalties. Here’s the crew.
Nick Paul. Leafs fans know the name, and some of us are still a little sore about it. Back in 2022, Paul scored twice in Game 7 against Toronto, including the series clincher. Now he’s ours. The Leafs grabbed the Mississauga native from Tampa on July 1 for Dennis Hildeby and two mid-round picks. With John Tavares hurt, Paul has been bumped up to centre Kirill Marchenko and Nylander on the second line. Against the Rangers, his extra effort late in a long shift kept the play alive and drew a penalty that set up the game-winner, and he didn’t even get a point for it. That might be the most blue collar sentence I’ve ever written.
Teddy Blueger. The fourth line centre and the backbone of the penalty kill. Blueger has led every Leafs forward in shorthanded ice time at 2:52 a night. He finally got rewarded against the Rangers when his redirect caught a lucky bounce and went in. Nobody deserved a bounce more.
Brandon Duhaime. He signed for three years at $2.6 million, arriving from Washington after a 165-hit, 65-block season on a penalty kill that finished top five in the league. He’ll also absolutely drop the gloves. He’s topped 13 minutes in three straight games, has four points in his last two, and in Edmonton he lifted Leon Draisaitl’s stick in the slot to kill what looked like a sure goal.
Zack MacEwen. Six-foot-four, 226 pounds, making $875,000. This is the guy who’ll run through a wall if you point at it. Against the Rangers his hard rush down the wing set up the fourth line’s first goal, and on Saturday he blew past Jake Walman on the outside and whacked home his own rebound.
Colton Sissons. The specialist. He’s winning 61.6 percent of his faceoffs, and the coaches regularly swap him onto the fourth line for defensive zone draws.
The captain has noticed. Matthews said that during a flat stretch against San Jose, the fourth line came out with a heavy shift and “kind of dragged us into the fight.” In Edmonton, that line combined for 12 hits.
The Blue Collar Blue Line
Troy Stecher is the poster boy right now. He’s on a $1.35 million deal and scored the winner against the Rangers with 40 seconds left. Two nights later he scored again in Edmonton, led the team with 24:21 of ice time, and may have saved two goals with his stick on an early penalty kill.
Jake McCabe leads the Leafs in shorthanded ice time at 3:20 a night. Against the Rangers he blocked four shots in 21 minutes, and when Zach Hyman bumped Anthony Stolarz on Saturday, McCabe made sure Hyman felt it.
Then there’s Chris Tanev, the gold standard of blue collar defencemen. He and Tavares are both out week to week, yet the Leafs still went 4-0-0 this week without them. Last year, losing those two would have sunk this team. Not this year.
The Numbers Behind the Lunch Pail
Remember last season? I’ve tried to forget too. Toronto finished 32-36-14 with a minus-46 goal differential, gave up more shots than anyone in the league, and missed the playoffs for the first time since 2015-16.
Now look at special teams. Last season the penalty kill finished eighth at 81.2 percent, and the power play sat right in the middle of the pack, 15th at 21.3 percent. This year the Leafs own the best penalty kill in the NHL at 95.2 percent, and the power play is clicking at 30.2 percent, fourth-best in the league.
That penalty kill is the corporals’ baby. It had gone 30 straight without allowing a goal before Edmonton finally scored one late in a game that was already over. Sissons, Blueger, Paul and Duhaime have all been big pieces of it, and assistant coach John Gruden has them playing quicker and more aggressive than any Leafs kill in years. That’s the Maple Leafs bottom six doing the job nobody claps for.
Why the Stars Are Flourishing
When you have real NCOs, your officers get to be officers.
Last season Matthews killed about 70 minutes of penalties over 60 games, roughly 1:10 a night. This year he’s down to 20 seconds a night shorthanded, and he put up 18 points in his first 12 games, sixth in the league. Those are legs he’s now spending on what he does best, and you can see it on the power play. It’s no coincidence the Leafs’ power play jumped from 15th to fourth the same year the stars stopped killing penalties. The blue collar guys take the shifts on the kill, and the officers show up to the power play fresh.
In Edmonton, Matthews led all Leafs forwards with just 17:13, while the Oilers had four forwards play more than him. Every Leafs line scored at 5-on-5. When your depth can do that, your stars don’t have to be superheroes every night.
Head coach Jim Hiller summed it up after the game: “It’s not just Matthews, it’s not just Nylander.” Even Mike Babcock admitted Toronto played “harder, longer, faster” than his team.
The Bottom Line
You can feel the difference. Last year, when things went sideways, this team folded. This year there’s a crew in the ditch that shows up every shift with their boots laced. Stars win you highlight packages. Corporals win you hockey games.
So here’s to the Maple Leafs bottom six and the blue collar boys on the back end. The guys on the cheap deals, eating the penalty kills, taking the ugly draws and blocking the shots nobody else wants to block. You won’t see their names on many jerseys in the stands. But you’ll see them in the standings.
Salute.
Sources: NHL.com, Maple Leafs Hotstove, The Globe and Mail, Global News, Yardbarker, The Leafs Nation, Leafs Lurker, Pro Hockey Rumors, The Hockey News, Squawka, StatMuse
NHL.com → https://www.nhl.com/news/toronto-maple-leafs-edmonton-oilers-game-recap-october-24-2026
Maple Leafs Hotstove → https://mapleleafshotstove.com/2026/10/25/game-review-maple-leafs-put-it-all-together-in-edmonton-cap-off-perfect-week-with-7-2-rout-of-oilers/
