Ten games into the 2026-27 season, the Toronto Maple Leafs are 4-4-2. They’ve scored 32 goals. They’ve allowed 32 goals. If you want one stat that sums up the Maple Leafs first 10 games, there it is.
On paper, that’s a .500 hockey team. But honestly? This team looks good. They’ve been in pretty much every game, even the ones they lost. Five of their six losses were one-goal games or went past regulation.
Quick reminder of where we came from. Last season was a disaster. The Leafs finished dead last in the Atlantic and missed the playoffs for the first time since 2016. Craig Berube got fired, John Chayka came in as GM, and Jim Hiller took over behind the bench. Then the hockey gods finally threw us a bone and we won the draft lottery. Gavin McKenna, first overall.
So here’s my grade after 10 games: B+.
I know. A B+ for a .500 team. Hear me out.
Maple Leafs First 10 Games: Every Result
| Date | Opponent | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sept. 29 | vs. Montreal | L 2-3 | 0-1-0 |
| Sept. 30 | vs. NY Islanders | W 2-1 | 1-1-0 |
| Oct. 3 | vs. Ottawa | L 2-3 | 1-2-0 |
| Oct. 6 | vs. Nashville | W 5-4 (OT) | 2-2-0 |
| Oct. 8 | at Vegas | L 3-4 (SO) | 2-2-1 |
| Oct. 10 | at Colorado | W 6-3 | 3-2-1 |
| Oct. 13 | at Utah | L 4-5 | 3-3-1 |
| Oct. 15 | vs. Buffalo | L 4-5 (OT) | 3-3-2 |
| Oct. 17 | vs. NY Islanders | L 1-4 | 3-4-2 |
| Oct. 19 | vs. San Jose | W 3-1 | 4-4-2 |

That’s points in six of 10 games. The highs are real. They won 6-3 in Colorado, and they came back from down 3-0 against Nashville before Matthews finished it in overtime. They also pushed Vegas to a shootout with Mitch Marner on the other bench. Didn’t love how that one ended, but fine.
The lows are real too. Blowing a 4-2 third-period lead to Buffalo at home is the kind of loss that sticks with you. Then the Islanders handled us 4-1 two nights later, and suddenly it was a three-game skid. Monday’s 3-1 win over San Jose finally stopped the bleeding.
Auston Matthews Looks Like Auston Matthews Again
This is the big one for me.
Matthews has 16 points (7 goals, 9 assists) through 10 games, which leads the team. He’s got three power-play goals and the OT winner against Nashville, and he’s skating like he isn’t thinking about his knee anymore.
Remember how last season ended for him. On March 12, Radko Gudas caught him knee-on-knee: Grade 3 MCL tear, season over, surgery a week later. That came on top of the upper-body stuff that dragged through 2024-25. So yeah, I was nervous about what version of 34 we’d get this year.
We’re getting the good one.
Monday against San Jose was the perfect snapshot. He coughed up the puck in his own end and Mason Marchment made him pay with the opener. Not great. Then with 12 seconds left in the second, on the power play, Marchenko found him from behind the net and he hammered a one-timer home to tie it. In the third he set up McKenna’s winner. That’s a goal and two assists. Make the mistake, own it, go fix it. That’s a captain.
William Nylander has been just as important, with 13 points (5 goals, 8 assists). He was sick enough Monday to miss the morning skate and still played. When Matthews and Nylander are both rolling, teams can’t load up on one line and call it a night.
Gavin McKenna: Sleepovers, Snipes and One Weird Night on the Bench
The first overall pick has 3 goals and 3 assists in his first 10 NHL games. For an 18-year-old in the most suffocating hockey market on earth, I’ll take that all day.
It didn’t start smooth. He went pointless in his first three games and the Toronto media was already sharpening the knives. Then on Oct. 6 against Nashville he got his first NHL point, took a pass from Matthews and ripped one top shelf over Juuse Saros. He called it “a big monkey off the back.” He’s also the first 18-year-old to score for the Leafs since Luke Richardson in 1987.
And then there’s the sleepover. McKenna spent the Sunday before that game at Matthews’ place. Sandwiches, football, bed. He’s also living with John Tavares this season. So the kid’s landlord is a former first overall pick, and his captain hosts sleepovers.
If that’s the secret to scoring in the NHL, put it on the team schedule.
Monday’s goal was even better. It came on the power play in the third period of a 1-1 game. He grabbed the puck at the bottom of the right circle, walked into the slot and beat Yaroslav Askarov glove side for the game-winner. It also came in his first head-to-head with Ivar Stenberg, the guy San Jose took second overall. Round one goes to McKenna.
He’s not perfect. He’s a minus-5 and still figuring out the defensive side of the game, which is exactly what 18-year-olds do.
Now, the Buffalo thing.
In the 5-4 OT loss to the Sabres, McKenna didn’t see the ice for the final 32:54. He finished with 6:36 of ice time. That was two nights after a career-high 17:08 in Utah, and he walked into the game on a four-game point streak.
Hiller’s explanation: “That was my decision.” The Leafs took a couple of penalties in the second, McKenna isn’t on the PK, he sat too long, and Hiller never got him back out. Hiller said it had nothing to do with how McKenna was playing and that it was on him.
My take? I respect a coach who owns it. But that didn’t sound like a message to the kid. It sounded like he lost track of him. Tavares went down early in the third and you’re down to 11 forwards. Buffalo is outshooting you 11-4 in the period. And your most skilled young player is glued to the bench? Come on, Jim.
To be fair, it’s one game, and McKenna answered with a game-winner four days later. But how Hiller handles this kid is officially on my watch list.
Kirill Marchenko’s Hat Trick (and the Overtime He’d Like Back)
First, the trade, because it still stings a little. The Leafs got Marchenko from Columbus the day before the season opener, and Matthew Knies was part of the package going the other way. Marchenko also signed a six-year, US$75 million extension that kicks in next season.
Losing Knies hurt. I’m not going to pretend otherwise. But Marchenko is starting to show why Chayka made the call.
Against Buffalo, in his 300th NHL game, he scored a hat trick, the fifth of his career and his first as a Leaf. Hiller had just moved him onto Tavares’ line, and one of those goals was filthy. Tavares fed him from the slot while Marchenko was gliding backwards across the crease, and he buried it on the power play.
Then in overtime he lost track of Owen Power, and Power scored the winner. After the game Marchenko put it on himself, straight up. The guy scores three goals and the first thing he does is take the blame for the loss. I like that a lot.
He’s up to 10 points (4 goals, 6 assists) in 10 games. Keep finishing like that and the Knies trade is going to look a whole lot better.
Cowan, Roslovic, Paul and Depth We Haven’t Had in Years
The biggest difference between this team and last year’s? You can actually roll four lines.
Easton Cowan isn’t new, but he’s playing like a different guy in his second season. He’s got 7 points (3 goals, 4 assists) and leads the team with two game-winning goals. One of them came in the 2-1 win over the Islanders that gave Hiller his first W in Toronto.
Jack Roslovic brings the wheels. He’s got 3 goals and 6 points, and he’s put 30 shots on net. He makes things happen off the rush, which this team needs when the top guys get shut down.
Nick Paul does the stuff that never makes the highlight pack. He’s a big body who plays heavy and doesn’t cheat. He’s chipped in 2 goals and 5 points too, including the empty-netter that iced Monday’s win.
Darren Raddysh is still looking for his first goal as a Leaf, but don’t read too much into that. He’s got 5 assists, 3 of them on the power play, and he’s leading the team in ice time at over 24 minutes a night. With 26 shots, one’s going in eventually.
The downside of all that depth is the line blender. Hiller keeps shuffling, and some nights it looks like guys aren’t sure who they’re playing with. That has to settle down.
Special Teams Are Carrying This Team
If you want the real reason this team is 4-4-2 and not 2-6-2, it’s special teams.
The penalty kill is first in the NHL at 96.9 per cent. Toronto has been shorthanded 32 times and given up exactly one power-play goal. One.
And it’s not like they’ve been disciplined. Through the first three games they were tied for the second-most minor penalties in the league, and the kill still didn’t crack. Guys like Colton Sissons and Brandon Duhaime have been fast and aggressive up ice, and it’s working.
The power play is fifth at 28.6 per cent. Both non-empty-net goals Monday came with the man advantage. Matthews already has three PP goals, and Marchenko and Nylander have two each.
Will a 97 per cent penalty kill last all year? Not a chance. Nobody does that. But if the kill stays anywhere close to elite while the 5-on-5 game catches up, this team wins a lot of hockey games.
Goaltending: Bob’s Been Better Than the Numbers Say
I wasn’t worried about the crease coming into this year. I’m less sure now. So far, Sergei Bobrovsky has been pretty good.
His numbers (2-3-2, .902, 2.96 GAA) don’t jump off the page, but watch the games. He’s a big reason they’ve been in some of those losses at all. Look at Buffalo. The Sabres outshot us 11-4 in the third, and the OT winner came off a blown coverage. That’s not on the goalie. Then Monday he made 30 saves against San Jose for his first home win as a Leaf. He looks calm back there, like a guy who’s won two Cups, and he’s given this team a chance just about every night.
Anthony Stolarz is the one I’m watching. He’s 2-1-0 but with an .875 save percentage, and there have been some big holes in his game early. That said, he can still steal you a game. He made 26 saves in the 2-1 win over the Islanders back in Game 2.
And I know what this guy can be. Two years ago Stolarz was playing out of his mind. He led the whole league in save percentage before a playoff injury knocked him out. Last season was a mess, with injuries pretty much all year. If he finds that 2024-25 form again, this tandem goes from solid to scary. I’m really hoping he does.
The Ugly: Blown Leads and a Banged-Up Lineup
Okay, now the stuff that keeps me up at night.
Blown leads. Buffalo is the one everyone remembers. They were up 4-2 after two, got outshot 11-4 in the third and lost in OT. Bobrovsky said afterwards they gave the Sabres way too much room, and he’s right. You can’t sit back on a two-goal lead in this league.
Health. Chris Tanev is out with an upper-body injury, and Tavares has been day-to-day since that collision with Josh Norris. Morgan Rielly is a minus-6 without a goal. This blue line already had questions. Losing Tanev doesn’t help.
Maple Leafs Report Card: B+ (Yes, Really)
If I graded purely on the standings, this is a C. A .500 team is a .500 team.
But that’s not the whole story. Matthews is healthy and leading the way. Nylander’s producing. McKenna is already scoring big goals. Marchenko is starting to earn that contract. Cowan took a step. Bob has been steady in net. The special teams are as good as anyone’s in the league. And honestly, this whole team just looks good. They’ve been in just about every game they’ve played, even the losses.
What keeps it from an A is just as obvious. They have to stop gifting away leads, Stolarz has to find his game, and Hiller has to settle on some line combos and stick with them.
My grade: B+.
What’s Next for the Leafs
The schedule doesn’t let up. This week the Leafs get their first look at Columbus since the trade, so Knies faces his old team and Marchenko faces his. Then it’s the Rangers at home, and a Western Canada swing: Edmonton on Saturday, Calgary on Monday.
And yeah, I live in Edmonton I’ll be at that game. I would very much like to not hear about the Oilers beating the Leafs all week at work.
Go Leafs Go!
Maple Leafs FAQ
What is the Maple Leafs’ record after 10 games?
The Leafs are 4-4-2 through their first 10 games of the 2026-27 season, with 32 goals for and 32 against.
How many points does Gavin McKenna have?
McKenna has 6 points (3 goals, 3 assists) in his first 10 NHL games, including the game-winning power-play goal against San Jose on Oct. 19.
Who leads the Maple Leafs in scoring?
Auston Matthews leads the team with 16 points (7 goals, 9 assists), followed by William Nylander (13) and Kirill Marchenko (10).
Who is the Maple Leafs head coach?
Jim Hiller, who was hired on June 17, 2026, to replace Craig Berube.
What grade are you giving the Leafs after 10 games? Drop it in the comments, and we’ll be getting into all of it on the 5 For Fighting Podcast too.
Sources: NHL.com, TSN, The Canadian Press, CTV News, theScore, The Hockey News, Maple Leafs Hot Stove, AFP
